Things to Remember While Using AI Audience

The idea of a synthetic audience is exciting instant feedback, scalable testing, and insights across countless personas at the click of a button. But just like any new research tool, it’s essential to understand both its strengths and its limits.

This article is a follow on for our previous blog: "5 Things Not To Expect From Synthetic Audience".

Synthetic audiences can accelerate testing and inspire new directions, but they’re not a replacement for real human understanding.

Knowing where they shine and where they fall short will help you use them wisely and get the most value out of your research efforts.

How to Set Proper Expectations

The key to using synthetic users successfully is to position them correctly within your research strategy:

Use Synthetic Users For:

  • Early directional feedback – Getting a quick read on whether an idea has potential before investing in full-scale research
  • Hypothesis generation – Identifying patterns and questions to explore more deeply with real consumers
  • Rapid iteration – Testing multiple variations to narrow down which concepts deserve human validation
  • Scale and speed – Simulating feedback across many segments when time and budget don't allow for comprehensive human panels

Rely on Real Users For:

  • Emotional and cultural insight – Understanding how people truly feel and why
  • Experiential feedback – Learning how products perform in real-world contexts
  • Final validation – Confirming that your concepts resonate before major investment
  • Strategic decisions – Making high-stakes choices that could significantly impact brand perception or business outcomes

Your Practical Framework

Here's a simple decision framework to guide when you should—and shouldn't—use synthetic users:

Start with synthetic users when:

  • You need speed and can tolerate directional rather than definitive insights
  • You're testing multiple concepts and need to narrow down options quickly
  • Budget constraints make large-scale human research impractical for early-stage exploration
  • You're exploring hypotheses before designing formal research studies

Move to human research when:

  • Emotional authenticity matters to the outcome
  • Cultural or demographic nuance is critical
  • You're making final go/no-go decisions on campaigns or products
  • Stakeholders need confidence that insights represent real consumer sentiment

When Synthetic Users Fall Short

Let's be specific about the types of research where synthetic users shouldn't be your primary tool:

  • High-stakes emotional research: Brand positioning around sensitive topics (mental health, body image, social justice) requires human depth.
  • Cultural localization: Understanding how messaging translates across cultures, languages, and regional contexts demands real human insight.
  • Behavioral observation: Watching how people actually interact with products, environments, or interfaces can't be simulated.
  • Niche or specialized audiences: B2B decision-makers, medical professionals, or other highly specialized segments often exhibit "herd mentality" and positivity bias when simulated, according to industry research.


The executives and teams who succeed with synthetic users are the ones who respect their limitations while leveraging their strengths.

Set realistic expectations, design hybrid workflows, and remember: the goal isn't to replace human insight it's to amplify your ability to understand and serve real consumers better and faster than ever before.

Read more